ECSE Takeaways

Have just finished Ekahau Site Survey course in Oxford and here are my takeaways from it:

  • Move away from 2.4GHz completely (inc. BYOD and Guest networks if possible) – don’t use it in modern world
  • Avoid using multiple SSIDs – beacons make the air dirty (have captured 60MB of beacons on one channel in 15m as a test)
  • Don’t install APs in corridors or hallways – signal from omni antennas propagates on hundreds of meters in free space
  • Make sure signal strength from 2nd strongest APs meet the main requirements if voice roaming is of concern. This is an equivalent of Cisco’s channel overlap of 10-20-30% requirement, which is hard to measure or prove.
  • If APs are installed in rooms/offices, put them away from windows to avoid waste of RF energy sent towards the street.
  • Mirrors do not significantly affect 2.4GHz (and 5GHz) – waves are still lengthy enough to penetrate through mirrors (?).
  • Adjacent channels interference is more destructive than co-channel interference, because devices on adjacent channels do not play nicely when they access the media (do not contend)
  • Radio Tap header information is added by the client. RSSI and noise levels reported by clients are virtual and vendor specific. NICs do not see RF shapes to measure noise and RSSI, but spectrum analyzers do.
  • Ch144 on 5GHz was introduced with 802.11ac
  • ESS cheats
    • Don’t use small objects to define scale, such as doors, desks and so on. This increases error level.
    • Use distance between objects to define scale on one floor, then use alignment points to define scale on all others.
    • Use coverage and coverage exclusion areas to make ESS reporting more accurate (coverage percentage)
    • If floors are more or less identical, draw one and duplicate the rest (using image swap trick). This will help to save a lot of time as this trick copies all objects, including alignment points and scales.
  • Useful Tools
    • Buffalo WMR-433: Very tiny WiFi router which can reach out on tens of meters
    • Theodolite: iOS app to measure azimuth, elevation, GPS coordinates – helps with outdoor deployments
    • NetScout Link Sprinter 300: A link tester. Checks all layers of TCP/IP protocols suite (physical/data link, network, transport and application). Capable to send results by email.
    • HORST: linux-based lightweight 802.11 analyzer with text interface
    • Kismet: linux-based wireless sniffer/packet capture software

That was a great week in Oxford. Hopefully I haven’t misinterpreted the information above 🙂

1 thought on “ECSE Takeaways

  1. scwifi

    Good post! I think the 2.4GHz conversation is a bit premature. From my perspective we’re in between pendulum swings – on one side, we have the genesis of Wi-Fi starting with 802.11 and b/g running in 2.4GHz and it ‘was hard’ dealing with three non overlapping channels. 802.11ac requires us to support 5GHz so we’re given a significant amount of breathing room in our designs (moving us to the middle of the pendulum). Way more channels makes our designs way easier as long as we’re not doing silly channel bonding. Unfortunately, we’re all going to be smacked really hard when 802.11ax is adopted in 2.4GHz (the other end of the pendulum swing). We lose the ability to ‘ignore’ 2.4GHz and things are going to get difficult again. Just understand that while it’s ‘getting safer’ today to move away from 2.4GHz because modern specifications for 802.11ac require it, tomorrows technology will bring it back into the fold (much like 802.11n) and you don’t want to be without skills in that area of the spectrum.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.